For this weeks assignment of evaluating myself as a communicator and having others also evaluate me, I would definitely have to say that there were some surprises. For the most part there were a lot of similarities in how I evaluated myself, as well as how the two other people I chose, in regards to the assessments on Communication Anxiety Inventory and Listening Styles Profile. But for me personally I think the biggest surprise came from my own evaluation of the assessment on the Verbal Aggressiveness Scale. And not only on how I evaluated myself, but also on how each of the two other people evaluated me.
I stated on this weeks application assignment that I was a little surprised to discover after my own self-evaluation that I actually scored in the second category of the significant level of the Verbal Aggressiveness Scale. "With little provocation, you might cross the line from"argumentativeness", which attacks a person's position or statements, and verbal aggression, which involves personal attacks and can be hurtful to the listener" ( Rubin, 2009). I think the reason it was such a surprise, is because I don't for one minute consider myself an aggressive person at all, especially when it comes to verbally attacking someone else's position or opinions. But after reviewing the initial questions from the assessment, I realized that I must have scored this way, at the significant level, due to the kind of person I am. And even though I am not usually an aggressive person I do know that I will definitely react in a certain manner, if I feel that either I or someone I care about, has been verbally attacked without any provocation.
The other thing that also surprised be, in regards to this assessment of the Verbal Aggressiveness Scale, is that both of my two chosen evaluators, a colleague and co-worker, and my own sister, did not receive the same results that I did. My colleague's results of the assessment scored me at the low level of the scale. "You are respectful of the viewpoints and intelligence of others, and attempt to change their minds with gentle, inoffensive suggestions that do not attack their self-concept" (Rubin, 2009). And for my family member, my sister her evaluations results actually scored me at the moderate level. "You maintain a good balance between respect and consideration for others' viewpoints, and the ability to argue fairly by attacking the facts of a position rather than the person holding that position" (Rubin, 2009).
So the fact that my scores of the assessments on the Verbal Aggressiveness Scale did differ from my own results, as well as the fact that I actually scored myself at a higher level then each of them really made me begin to wonder. And also ask myself the question, "When it comes to self-evaluation, are we actually tougher and more critical of ourselves, then others who know us are?". If I had to now answer this question based on the experience of this assignment, of evaluating ourselves, I would definitely have to say, "Yes".
All in all I would definitely have to say that I really gained some important and relevant insights, especially when it comes to becoming an effective and positive communicator in this field of early childhood studies. And I believe it is assignments such as this where we have to complete not only self-evaluations, but also have others to evaluate us, is very imperative to us discovering some important facts. The kind of facts that will help us to not only identify our strengths, but also to help us to be more aware of our own weakenesses as well. So hopefully one day we then will be able to take the necessary steps of becoming more confident and positive communicators, not only in our personal lives, but also in our professional careers as educators and teachers in the classroom.
References:
Rubin, R. B., Palmgreen, P., & Sypher, H. E. (Eds.) (2009). Communication research measures: A sourcebook. New York: Routledge.
Rubin, R. B., Rubin, A. M., Graham, E. E., Perse, E. M., & Seibold, D. R. (Eds.) (2009). Communication research measures II: A sourcebook. New York: Routledge.